August 16th, 2012
Are we at a bullish or bearish pivot point? If you’re looking for market advice from CNBC you’re looking at the wrong place. The best way to get viewers is to create and stimulate controversy and that’s what CNBC does every single day. You get a lot of different opinions but you can’t get just one straight opinion that you can act on.
A perfect example was how they juxtaposed, on two successive days earlier this week, Jeremy Segal of Wharton Business School articulating a bullish outlook followed the next day by Doug Kass of Seabreeze Partners pushing a bearish perspective today. Interestingly, couched inside both opinions were opposing opinions on the impact of Romney’s selection of Ryan as his V.P. candidate:
- First, they put on Jeremy Siegel who endorsed the Ryan selection because of Ryan’s budget-cutting efforts and suggested that, as a consequence, the market will advance to around 1500.
- Kass came the next day suggesting than Ryan’s selection will lead to Obama’s reelection and driving the the market down to 1300 (interestingly, he started his pitch by using an invalid and inaccurate technical view of the market) because of Ryan’s conservative history and his known hostility towards Bernanke. Kass believes that the highs for the market have already been made.
So what is the average investor to do? Which opinion should we embrace? Or is watching merely a total waste of time.
If you’re obsessed with trying to guess the upcoming election’s impact on the market then you have to come up with answers to a series of difficult and highly subjective questions:
- Is a Romney win looked on favorably or not? an Obama reelection?
- Is the market already discounting the election of one or another candidate?
- If there was a market bias towards one candidate vs. the other then would an upset create an adverse market reaction after the election?
- How does control of Congress factor into the equation?
- What if Congress is split?
- What if Congress is controlled by the same party?
- What if control of both houses goes to the opposing party?
And those are just the questions that easily roll off the top of my head. Clearly spending much time trying to answer these questions is futile. Making investment decisions today based on what you have figured out to be the correct answer to each of these questions is foolish.
There can only be four options that drive your investment decisions today based on your prediction of an event in a little more than 11 weeks. Sell, buy, do nothing or ignore the election and base your decision on what’s happening today.
My answer is always to “follow the herd” rather than make my own fundamental analysis. I’m not proud; I want to do what the majority of the money sloshing around the market is doing today rather than trying to second guess whether they are right or wrong in going in the direction that they are. I want to know how strong the market’s momentum is and the direction in which it’s driving. As far as I’m concerned, there’s no doubt as to that answer.
For the first time since October 2009, the market next week as measured by an index of the 500 stocks comprising the S&P 500 Index will create a situation where the market’s current level will be above its average level over the prior 50 days which will be higher than its level over the average of the prior 100 days which will be over the average of the prior 200 days. Finally, they will all be higher than the market’s average level for the past 300 trading days. The same will soon also be true for the index of stocks comprising the Dow Jones 30 Industrials and, for the Dow Theory followers, the DJ Transports.
On July 17, four weeks ago when the S&P 500 closed at 1357, I described the market’s consolidation flag and went out on a limb to say a cross above 1420-25 would lead to the market climbing to 1575. Today, the market closed at 1415, or 4.27% above that July 17 close. Hopefully, all the uncertainties and “Alerts” and “Breaking News” and “Earnings Season” jabbered about on CNBC didn’t scare you away from being in the market. It didn’t scare the big money herd who have been accumulating stocks and, in the process, forcing prices higher. They may reverse course but, I doubt it more ever day.
Come back often to check on the market’s progress. Better yet, become a Member and see where I’m putting my money to take advantage of this advance … while it lasts …and the Industry Groups from which I select the stocks I buy.